Docs

How Redacted compares

Updated 30 October 20266 min read

Most privacy tools on public chains are either a pool you pass your coins through or a shielded wallet with a few private actions added on. Redacted is built to be the place where your DeFi life happens. You sign in with the wallet you already use, your balance holds real coins from many chains, and you trade, lend, borrow and stake on Rujira without anyone being able to connect it to your public address. With bunker mode, your account, your proofs and your signatures run on hashes from day one.

The table compares Redacted with three well-known privacy protocols and with Houdini, a private swap service. It reflects what each one offers as of October 2026.

How Redacted compares Feature comparison of Redacted, Railgun, Privacy Pools, Umbra and Houdini as of October 2026. Private account from the wallet you already have, with no new seed phrase: Redacted yes, Railgun no, Privacy Pools yes, Umbra yes, Houdini no. Real BTC, ETH and other native coins in one private balance, with no bridges or wrapped tokens: Redacted yes, Railgun no, Privacy Pools no, Umbra no, Houdini no. Private swaps: Redacted yes, Railgun yes, Privacy Pools yes, Umbra yes, Houdini yes. Private limit orders on an orderbook: Redacted yes, Railgun no, Privacy Pools no, Umbra no, Houdini no. Private lending and borrowing: Redacted yes, Railgun yes, Privacy Pools no, Umbra no, Houdini no. Private staking and yield: Redacted yes, Railgun yes, Privacy Pools yes, Umbra no, Houdini no. Deposits checked against known hacks and sanctions lists: Redacted yes, Railgun yes, Privacy Pools yes, Umbra yes, Houdini yes. One company approves every deposit: Redacted no, Railgun no, Privacy Pools yes, Umbra yes, Houdini yes. Checks decided by an independent, bonded node network: Redacted yes, Railgun no, Privacy Pools no, Umbra no, Houdini no. Viewing keys to share your history with an auditor: Redacted yes, Railgun yes, Privacy Pools yes, Umbra yes, Houdini no. Withdrawals always open, nobody can freeze your funds: Redacted yes, Railgun yes, Privacy Pools yes, Umbra yes, Houdini partly. No sign-up and no identity checks: Redacted yes, Railgun yes, Privacy Pools yes, Umbra yes, Houdini partly. Proofs built from hashes only, with no trusted setup: Redacted yes, Railgun no, Privacy Pools no, Umbra no, Houdini no. Nothing on chain that a quantum computer could decrypt later: Redacted yes, Railgun no, Privacy Pools partly, Umbra no, Houdini partly. Partly means that Houdini needs no account, while its exchange partners can hold a swap for a compliance review and ask for identity or source-of-funds information, and on the last row that Privacy Pools writes nothing encrypted in its first version and does in its second, and that Houdini writes nothing itself while its optional Monero hop rests on elliptic curves. Redacted’s last two rows describe bunker mode, which is there from day one next to standard mode. Redacted Railgun Privacy Pools Umbra Houdini Private account from the wallet you already have, with no new seed phrase Real BTC, ETH and other native coins in one private balance, with no bridges or wrapped tokens Private swaps Private limit orders on an orderbook Private lending and borrowing Private staking and yield Deposits checked against known hacks and sanctions lists One company approves every deposit Checks decided by an independent, bonded node network Viewing keys to share your history with an auditor Withdrawals always open, nobody can freeze your funds No sign-up and no identity checks Proofs built from hashes only, with no trusted setup Nothing on chain that a quantum computer could decrypt later Partly. Houdini needs no account, and its exchange partners can hold a swap for a compliance review and askfor identity or source-of-funds information. On the last row, Privacy Pools writes nothing encrypted in its firstversion and does in its second, and Houdini writes nothing itself while its optional Monero hop rests on elliptic curves. Redacted’s last two rows describe bunker mode, which is there from day one next to standard mode.

A few notes on the rows. Railgun brings privacy to EVM chains and supports private swaps, yield and liquidity through integrations, and it uses its own wallet with a separate recovery phrase and view-only keys. Privacy Pools runs two versions. The first focuses on private deposits and withdrawals of ETH and tokens, with a single association set provider that vets deposits and a ragequit that returns rejected deposits to their sender, and the second, live since September 2026, adds private transfers, swaps, Aave yield and viewing keys. Umbra is a private wallet on Solana with shielded transfers and swaps, and it adds viewing keys, risk screening and geo-blocking on top. Houdini offers private swaps across many chains without an account, and it routes each swap through two exchange partners and an intermediate coin. Each partner runs its own compliance checks and can hold a swap during a review and ask for identity or source-of-funds information, which is why Houdini's rows on withdrawals and identity checks are marked as partly.

The last two rows are about quantum safety, and Redacted's marks there describe bunker mode, which is there from day one next to standard mode. Every Redacted account proves with STARKs built from hashes and writes nothing encrypted to the chain, and in bunker mode the account itself rests on hashes too, where a standard account rests on its wallet's key. Railgun, Privacy Pools and Umbra all prove with Groth16 over the BN254 curve, which needs a trusted setup and rests on elliptic curves. Railgun and Umbra, and Privacy Pools in its second version, also write notes to the chain that are encrypted with elliptic-curve keys, so a future quantum computer could read them. None of them has announced a post-quantum mode.

Redacted brings the best of these approaches together in one place. You get full access to DeFi on Rujira, real coins from every major chain in one private balance and checks run by independent nodes, all from the wallet you already use, and Redacted's proofs are built from hashes alone. New money waits about two hours, which makes it harder to link a deposit to what you do next, and your withdrawals stay open whatever happens. Read more in How the privacy works, Bunker mode, Compliance and How the node network works.

Sources

The comparison uses each project's own documentation and launch coverage, retrieved on 1 October 2026, and for Privacy Pools V2 and quantum safety on 12 October 2026. The addresses are given as text.

  • For Railgun, the Railgun documentation (docs.railgun.org/wiki), Messari's report "RAILGUN: Privacy Infrastructure for DeFi" (messari.io/report/railgun-privacy-infrastructure-for-defi), the trusted setup page (docs.railgun.org/wiki/learn/privacy-system/trusted-setup-ceremony) and L2BEAT's Railgun privacy page (l2beat.com/privacy/projects/railgun), retrieved 1 and 12 October 2026.
  • For Privacy Pools, 0xbow's guide "Getting Started with Privacy Pools" (0xbow.io/blog/getting-started-with-privacy-pools), the Privacy Pools V2 documentation (privacy-pools-v2-docs.vercel.app) and the V2 ceremony repository (github.com/0xbow-io/v2-ceremony), retrieved 1 and 12 October 2026.
  • For Umbra, The Block's article "Umbra opens privacy wallet to the public on Solana" (27 March 2026, theblock.co), Arcium's announcement "Umbra is now open to the public" (arcium.substack.com) and the Umbra SDK documentation on its proofs, keys and mixer (sdk.umbraprivacy.com), retrieved 1 and 12 October 2026.
  • For Houdini, the Houdini documentation on private swaps (docs.houdiniswap.com/overview/swaps-and-transfers/private-swaps), the Houdini Terms of Service (last updated 14 July 2026, linked from houdiniswap.com) and Houdini's replies to user reviews on Trustpilot (24 August 2026, trustpilot.com/review/houdiniswap.com), retrieved 1 October 2026.
  • For quantum safety, ethereum.org's page "Zero-knowledge proofs" (ethereum.org/en/zero-knowledge-proofs) and L2BEAT's privacy framework (l2beat.com/privacy), retrieved 12 October 2026.

If something here has changed, tell us through the official channels and we update the table.